Euler Problem 67 - Maximum Path Sum II: Difference between revisions

Here we give a solution to the Euler Problem 67. The purpose is to show:

• that the encoding in B is compact and hopefully readable
• that by using ProB we get dynamic programming automatically.

The Euler Problem 67 Description

For convenience,here is the description from the official site of the Euler Problem 67:

By starting at the top of the triangle below and moving to adjacent numbers on the row below, the maximum total from top to bottom is 23.

3
7 4
2 4 6
8 5 9 3

That is, 3 + 7 + 4 + 9 = 23.

Find the maximum total from top to bottom in triangle.txt (right click and 'Save Link/Target As...'), a 15K text file containing a triangle with one-hundred rows.

NOTE: This is a much more difficult version of Problem 18. It is not possible to try every route to solve this problem, as there are 299 altogether! If you could check one trillion (1012) routes every second it would take over twenty billion years to check them all. There is an efficient algorithm to solve it. ;o)

The solution in B

A solution in B is as follows, where the data for the triangle is held in the file triangle_Euler67.def:

MACHINE Euler_Problem_067
DEFINITIONS
 "triangle_Euler67.def";
 SET_PREF_TIME_OUT == 5000
CONSTANTS  n, Sol, OptimalSolution, TriangleC
PROPERTIES TriangleC = Triangle &
n = size (TriangleC) &

Sol : 1..n --> seq(INTEGER) &
Sol(n) = TriangleC(n) /* Initialisation */
&
! i. (i:1..(n-1) =>
  (size(Sol(i)) = size(TriangleC(i))
   & !j.(j: 1..size(TriangleC(i)) => Sol(i)(j) = TriangleC(i)(j)+max({Sol(i+1)(j),Sol(i+1)(j+1)}))
  )
  )
 & OptimalSolution = Sol(1)(1)
ASSERTIONS
 OptimalSolution = 7273;
 n = 100
END

This problem was solved on a MacBook Air 1.7 GHz using ProB 1.4.0rc2 in under 2.5 seconds:

$ probcli Euler_Problem_067.mch -init
% set_pref(TIME_OUT,time_out,5000)
% found_enumeration_of_constants(1990,2260)
% backtrack(found_enumeration_of_constants(1990,2260))

You can also check the assertions using the command probcli Euler_Problem_067.mch -init -assertions in the same time:

$ probcliEuler_Problem_067.mch -init -assertions
% set_pref(TIME_OUT,time_out,5000)
% found_enumeration_of_constants(2060,2350)
% backtrack(found_enumeration_of_constants(2060,2350))
% Checking ASSERTIONS: 
Checking Static Assertions

==> OptimalSolution = 7273
TRUE
TRUE  (0 ms + 0 ms = 0 ms)

==> n = 100
TRUE
TRUE  (0 ms + 0 ms = 0 ms)
=======
SUMMARY
=======
2 predicates: 2 TRUE, 0 FALSE, 0 UNKNOWN (0 timeouts)
0 ms to analyse
Checking Dynamic Assertions
=======
SUMMARY
=======
0 predicates: 0 TRUE, 0 FALSE, 0 UNKNOWN (0 timeouts)
0 ms to analyse
[total/2,total_after_expansion/2,true/2,true_after_expansion/2,false/0,false_after_expansion/0,unknown/0,unknown_after_expansion/0,timeout/0,runtime/0,enum_warning/0]
% Finished checking ASSERTIONS

An interesting fact is the that dynamic programming is done automatically by ProB's constraint solving. In the Fibonacci Numbers with Automatic Dynamic Programming page we explain this fact on a simpler example.

A picat solution is also available. Compared to our solution, in the Picat solution the order of computation is directly encoded in the Picat program. Here, ProB has to infer the order of computation itself; this obviously comes at a performance price compared to a more imperative encoding of the problem.

The runtimes could be improved by enforcing the proper order of computation explicitly inside the model (e.g., by putting the computation of rows into B operations and use model checking or animation to solve the problem).

The data file for the Euler Problem 67

Contents of the definition file triangle_Euler67.def are:

DEFINITIONS
Triangle == [
[59],
[73, 41],
[52, 40, 09],
[26, 53, 06, 34],
[10, 51, 87, 86, 81],
[61, 95, 66, 57, 25, 68],
[90, 81, 80, 38, 92, 67, 73],
[30, 28, 51, 76, 81, 18, 75, 44],
[84, 14, 95, 87, 62, 81, 17, 78, 58],
[21, 46, 71, 58, 02, 79, 62, 39, 31, 09],
[56, 34, 35, 53, 78, 31, 81, 18, 90, 93, 15],
[78, 53, 04, 21, 84, 93, 32, 13, 97, 11, 37, 51],
[45, 03, 81, 79, 05, 18, 78, 86, 13, 30, 63, 99, 95],
[39, 87, 96, 28, 03, 38, 42, 17, 82, 87, 58, 07, 22, 57],
[06, 17, 51, 17, 07, 93, 09, 07, 75, 97, 95, 78, 87, 08, 53],
[67, 66, 59, 60, 88, 99, 94, 65, 55, 77, 55, 34, 27, 53, 78, 28],
[76, 40, 41, 04, 87, 16, 09, 42, 75, 69, 23, 97, 30, 60, 10, 79, 87],
[12, 10, 44, 26, 21, 36, 32, 84, 98, 60, 13, 12, 36, 16, 63, 31, 91, 35],
[70, 39, 06, 05, 55, 27, 38, 48, 28, 22, 34, 35, 62, 62, 15, 14, 94, 89, 86],
[66, 56, 68, 84, 96, 21, 34, 34, 34, 81, 62, 40, 65, 54, 62, 05, 98, 03, 02, 60],
[38, 89, 46, 37, 99, 54, 34, 53, 36, 14, 70, 26, 02, 90, 45, 13, 31, 61, 83, 73, 47],
[36, 10, 63, 96, 60, 49, 41, 05, 37, 42, 14, 58, 84, 93, 96, 17, 09, 43, 05, 43, 06, 59],
[66, 57, 87, 57, 61, 28, 37, 51, 84, 73, 79, 15, 39, 95, 88, 87, 43, 39, 11, 86, 77, 74, 18],
[54, 42, 05, 79, 30, 49, 99, 73, 46, 37, 50, 02, 45, 09, 54, 52, 27, 95, 27, 65, 19, 45, 26, 45],
[71, 39, 17, 78, 76, 29, 52, 90, 18, 99, 78, 19, 35, 62, 71, 19, 23, 65, 93, 85, 49, 33, 75, 09, 02],
[33, 24, 47, 61, 60, 55, 32, 88, 57, 55, 91, 54, 46, 57, 07, 77, 98, 52, 80, 99, 24, 25, 46, 78, 79, 05],
[92, 09, 13, 55, 10, 67, 26, 78, 76, 82, 63, 49, 51, 31, 24, 68, 05, 57, 07, 54, 69, 21, 67, 43, 17, 63, 12],
[24, 59, 06, 08, 98, 74, 66, 26, 61, 60, 13, 03, 09, 09, 24, 30, 71, 08, 88, 70, 72, 70, 29, 90, 11, 82, 41, 34],
[66, 82, 67, 04, 36, 60, 92, 77, 91, 85, 62, 49, 59, 61, 30, 90, 29, 94, 26, 41, 89, 04, 53, 22, 83, 41, 09, 74, 90],
[48, 28, 26, 37, 28, 52, 77, 26, 51, 32, 18, 98, 79, 36, 62, 13, 17, 08, 19, 54, 89, 29, 73, 68, 42, 14, 08, 16, 70, 37],
[37, 60, 69, 70, 72, 71, 09, 59, 13, 60, 38, 13, 57, 36, 09, 30, 43, 89, 30, 39, 15, 02, 44, 73, 05, 73, 26, 63, 56, 86, 12],
[55, 55, 85, 50, 62, 99, 84, 77, 28, 85, 03, 21, 27, 22, 19, 26, 82, 69, 54, 04, 13, 07, 85, 14, 01, 15, 70, 59, 89, 95, 10, 19],
[04, 09, 31, 92, 91, 38, 92, 86, 98, 75, 21, 05, 64, 42, 62, 84, 36, 20, 73, 42, 21, 23, 22, 51, 51, 79, 25, 45, 85, 53, 03, 43, 22],
[75, 63, 02, 49, 14, 12, 89, 14, 60, 78, 92, 16, 44, 82, 38, 30, 72, 11, 46, 52, 90, 27, 08, 65, 78, 03, 85, 41, 57, 79, 39, 52, 33, 48],
[78, 27, 56, 56, 39, 13, 19, 43, 86, 72, 58, 95, 39, 07, 04, 34, 21, 98, 39, 15, 39, 84, 89, 69, 84, 46, 37, 57, 59, 35, 59, 50, 26, 15, 93],
[42, 89, 36, 27, 78, 91, 24, 11, 17, 41, 05, 94, 07, 69, 51, 96, 03, 96, 47, 90, 90, 45, 91, 20, 50, 56, 10, 32, 36, 49, 04, 53, 85, 92, 25, 65],
[52, 09, 61, 30, 61, 97, 66, 21, 96, 92, 98, 90, 06, 34, 96, 60, 32, 69, 68, 33, 75, 84, 18, 31, 71, 50, 84, 63, 03, 03, 19, 11, 28, 42, 75, 45, 45],
[61, 31, 61, 68, 96, 34, 49, 39, 05, 71, 76, 59, 62, 67, 06, 47, 96, 99, 34, 21, 32, 47, 52, 07, 71, 60, 42, 72, 94, 56, 82, 83, 84, 40, 94, 87, 82, 46],
[01, 20, 60, 14, 17, 38, 26, 78, 66, 81, 45, 95, 18, 51, 98, 81, 48, 16, 53, 88, 37, 52, 69, 95, 72, 93, 22, 34, 98, 20, 54, 27, 73, 61, 56, 63, 60, 34, 63],
[93, 42, 94, 83, 47, 61, 27, 51, 79, 79, 45, 01, 44, 73, 31, 70, 83, 42, 88, 25, 53, 51, 30, 15, 65, 94, 80, 44, 61, 84, 12, 77, 02, 62, 02, 65, 94, 42, 14, 94],
[32, 73, 09, 67, 68, 29, 74, 98, 10, 19, 85, 48, 38, 31, 85, 67, 53, 93, 93, 77, 47, 67, 39, 72, 94, 53, 18, 43, 77, 40, 78, 32, 29, 59, 24, 06, 02, 83, 50, 60, 66],
[32, 01, 44, 30, 16, 51, 15, 81, 98, 15, 10, 62, 86, 79, 50, 62, 45, 60, 70, 38, 31, 85, 65, 61, 64, 06, 69, 84, 14, 22, 56, 43, 09, 48, 66, 69, 83, 91, 60, 40, 36, 61],
[92, 48, 22, 99, 15, 95, 64, 43, 01, 16, 94, 02, 99, 19, 17, 69, 11, 58, 97, 56, 89, 31, 77, 45, 67, 96, 12, 73, 08, 20, 36, 47, 81, 44, 50, 64, 68, 85, 40, 81, 85, 52, 09],
[91, 35, 92, 45, 32, 84, 62, 15, 19, 64, 21, 66, 06, 01, 52, 80, 62, 59, 12, 25, 88, 28, 91, 50, 40, 16, 22, 99, 92, 79, 87, 51, 21, 77, 74, 77, 07, 42, 38, 42, 74, 83, 02, 05],
[46, 19, 77, 66, 24, 18, 05, 32, 02, 84, 31, 99, 92, 58, 96, 72, 91, 36, 62, 99, 55, 29, 53, 42, 12, 37, 26, 58, 89, 50, 66, 19, 82, 75, 12, 48, 24, 87, 91, 85, 02, 07, 03, 76, 86],
[99, 98, 84, 93, 07, 17, 33, 61, 92, 20, 66, 60, 24, 66, 40, 30, 67, 05, 37, 29, 24, 96, 03, 27, 70, 62, 13, 04, 45, 47, 59, 88, 43, 20, 66, 15, 46, 92, 30, 04, 71, 66, 78, 70, 53, 99],
[67, 60, 38, 06, 88, 04, 17, 72, 10, 99, 71, 07, 42, 25, 54, 05, 26, 64, 91, 50, 45, 71, 06, 30, 67, 48, 69, 82, 08, 56, 80, 67, 18, 46, 66, 63, 01, 20, 08, 80, 47, 07, 91, 16, 03, 79, 87],
[18, 54, 78, 49, 80, 48, 77, 40, 68, 23, 60, 88, 58, 80, 33, 57, 11, 69, 55, 53, 64, 02, 94, 49, 60, 92, 16, 35, 81, 21, 82, 96, 25, 24, 96, 18, 02, 05, 49, 03, 50, 77, 06, 32, 84, 27, 18, 38],
[68, 01, 50, 04, 03, 21, 42, 94, 53, 24, 89, 05, 92, 26, 52, 36, 68, 11, 85, 01, 04, 42, 02, 45, 15, 06, 50, 04, 53, 73, 25, 74, 81, 88, 98, 21, 67, 84, 79, 97, 99, 20, 95, 04, 40, 46, 02, 58, 87],
[94, 10, 02, 78, 88, 52, 21, 03, 88, 60, 06, 53, 49, 71, 20, 91, 12, 65, 07, 49, 21, 22, 11, 41, 58, 99, 36, 16, 09, 48, 17, 24, 52, 36, 23, 15, 72, 16, 84, 56, 02, 99, 43, 76, 81, 71, 29, 39, 49, 17],
[64, 39, 59, 84, 86, 16, 17, 66, 03, 09, 43, 06, 64, 18, 63, 29, 68, 06, 23, 07, 87, 14, 26, 35, 17, 12, 98, 41, 53, 64, 78, 18, 98, 27, 28, 84, 80, 67, 75, 62, 10, 11, 76, 90, 54, 10, 05, 54, 41, 39, 66],
[43, 83, 18, 37, 32, 31, 52, 29, 95, 47, 08, 76, 35, 11, 04, 53, 35, 43, 34, 10, 52, 57, 12, 36, 20, 39, 40, 55, 78, 44, 07, 31, 38, 26, 08, 15, 56, 88, 86, 01, 52, 62, 10, 24, 32, 05, 60, 65, 53, 28, 57, 99],
[03, 50, 03, 52, 07, 73, 49, 92, 66, 80, 01, 46, 08, 67, 25, 36, 73, 93, 07, 42, 25, 53, 13, 96, 76, 83, 87, 90, 54, 89, 78, 22, 78, 91, 73, 51, 69, 09, 79, 94, 83, 53, 09, 40, 69, 62, 10, 79, 49, 47, 03, 81, 30],
[71, 54, 73, 33, 51, 76, 59, 54, 79, 37, 56, 45, 84, 17, 62, 21, 98, 69, 41, 95, 65, 24, 39, 37, 62, 03, 24, 48, 54, 64, 46, 82, 71, 78, 33, 67, 09, 16, 96, 68, 52, 74, 79, 68, 32, 21, 13, 78, 96, 60, 09, 69, 20, 36],
[73, 26, 21, 44, 46, 38, 17, 83, 65, 98, 07, 23, 52, 46, 61, 97, 33, 13, 60, 31, 70, 15, 36, 77, 31, 58, 56, 93, 75, 68, 21, 36, 69, 53, 90, 75, 25, 82, 39, 50, 65, 94, 29, 30, 11, 33, 11, 13, 96, 02, 56, 47, 07, 49, 02],
[76, 46, 73, 30, 10, 20, 60, 70, 14, 56, 34, 26, 37, 39, 48, 24, 55, 76, 84, 91, 39, 86, 95, 61, 50, 14, 53, 93, 64, 67, 37, 31, 10, 84, 42, 70, 48, 20, 10, 72, 60, 61, 84, 79, 69, 65, 99, 73, 89, 25, 85, 48, 92, 56, 97, 16],
[03, 14, 80, 27, 22, 30, 44, 27, 67, 75, 79, 32, 51, 54, 81, 29, 65, 14, 19, 04, 13, 82, 04, 91, 43, 40, 12, 52, 29, 99, 07, 76, 60, 25, 01, 07, 61, 71, 37, 92, 40, 47, 99, 66, 57, 01, 43, 44, 22, 40, 53, 53, 09, 69, 26, 81, 07],
[49, 80, 56, 90, 93, 87, 47, 13, 75, 28, 87, 23, 72, 79, 32, 18, 27, 20, 28, 10, 37, 59, 21, 18, 70, 04, 79, 96, 03, 31, 45, 71, 81, 06, 14, 18, 17, 05, 31, 50, 92, 79, 23, 47, 09, 39, 47, 91, 43, 54, 69, 47, 42, 95, 62, 46, 32, 85],
[37, 18, 62, 85, 87, 28, 64, 05, 77, 51, 47, 26, 30, 65, 05, 70, 65, 75, 59, 80, 42, 52, 25, 20, 44, 10, 92, 17, 71, 95, 52, 14, 77, 13, 24, 55, 11, 65, 26, 91, 01, 30, 63, 15, 49, 48, 41, 17, 67, 47, 03, 68, 20, 90, 98, 32, 04, 40, 68],
[90, 51, 58, 60, 06, 55, 23, 68, 05, 19, 76, 94, 82, 36, 96, 43, 38, 90, 87, 28, 33, 83, 05, 17, 70, 83, 96, 93, 06, 04, 78, 47, 80, 06, 23, 84, 75, 23, 87, 72, 99, 14, 50, 98, 92, 38, 90, 64, 61, 58, 76, 94, 36, 66, 87, 80, 51, 35, 61, 38],
[57, 95, 64, 06, 53, 36, 82, 51, 40, 33, 47, 14, 07, 98, 78, 65, 39, 58, 53, 06, 50, 53, 04, 69, 40, 68, 36, 69, 75, 78, 75, 60, 03, 32, 39, 24, 74, 47, 26, 90, 13, 40, 44, 71, 90, 76, 51, 24, 36, 50, 25, 45, 70, 80, 61, 80, 61, 43, 90, 64, 11],
[18, 29, 86, 56, 68, 42, 79, 10, 42, 44, 30, 12, 96, 18, 23, 18, 52, 59, 02, 99, 67, 46, 60, 86, 43, 38, 55, 17, 44, 93, 42, 21, 55, 14, 47, 34, 55, 16, 49, 24, 23, 29, 96, 51, 55, 10, 46, 53, 27, 92, 27, 46, 63, 57, 30, 65, 43, 27, 21, 20, 24, 83],
[81, 72, 93, 19, 69, 52, 48, 01, 13, 83, 92, 69, 20, 48, 69, 59, 20, 62, 05, 42, 28, 89, 90, 99, 32, 72, 84, 17, 08, 87, 36, 03, 60, 31, 36, 36, 81, 26, 97, 36, 48, 54, 56, 56, 27, 16, 91, 08, 23, 11, 87, 99, 33, 47, 02, 14, 44, 73, 70, 99, 43, 35, 33],
[90, 56, 61, 86, 56, 12, 70, 59, 63, 32, 01, 15, 81, 47, 71, 76, 95, 32, 65, 80, 54, 70, 34, 51, 40, 45, 33, 04, 64, 55, 78, 68, 88, 47, 31, 47, 68, 87, 03, 84, 23, 44, 89, 72, 35, 08, 31, 76, 63, 26, 90, 85, 96, 67, 65, 91, 19, 14, 17, 86, 04, 71, 32, 95],
[37, 13, 04, 22, 64, 37, 37, 28, 56, 62, 86, 33, 07, 37, 10, 44, 52, 82, 52, 06, 19, 52, 57, 75, 90, 26, 91, 24, 06, 21, 14, 67, 76, 30, 46, 14, 35, 89, 89, 41, 03, 64, 56, 97, 87, 63, 22, 34, 03, 79, 17, 45, 11, 53, 25, 56, 96, 61, 23, 18, 63, 31, 37, 37, 47],
[77, 23, 26, 70, 72, 76, 77, 04, 28, 64, 71, 69, 14, 85, 96, 54, 95, 48, 06, 62, 99, 83, 86, 77, 97, 75, 71, 66, 30, 19, 57, 90, 33, 01, 60, 61, 14, 12, 90, 99, 32, 77, 56, 41, 18, 14, 87, 49, 10, 14, 90, 64, 18, 50, 21, 74, 14, 16, 88, 05, 45, 73, 82, 47, 74, 44],
[22, 97, 41, 13, 34, 31, 54, 61, 56, 94, 03, 24, 59, 27, 98, 77, 04, 09, 37, 40, 12, 26, 87, 09, 71, 70, 07, 18, 64, 57, 80, 21, 12, 71, 83, 94, 60, 39, 73, 79, 73, 19, 97, 32, 64, 29, 41, 07, 48, 84, 85, 67, 12, 74, 95, 20, 24, 52, 41, 67, 56, 61, 29, 93, 35, 72, 69],
[72, 23, 63, 66, 01, 11, 07, 30, 52, 56, 95, 16, 65, 26, 83, 90, 50, 74, 60, 18, 16, 48, 43, 77, 37, 11, 99, 98, 30, 94, 91, 26, 62, 73, 45, 12, 87, 73, 47, 27, 01, 88, 66, 99, 21, 41, 95, 80, 02, 53, 23, 32, 61, 48, 32, 43, 43, 83, 14, 66, 95, 91, 19, 81, 80, 67, 25, 88],
[08, 62, 32, 18, 92, 14, 83, 71, 37, 96, 11, 83, 39, 99, 05, 16, 23, 27, 10, 67, 02, 25, 44, 11, 55, 31, 46, 64, 41, 56, 44, 74, 26, 81, 51, 31, 45, 85, 87, 09, 81, 95, 22, 28, 76, 69, 46, 48, 64, 87, 67, 76, 27, 89, 31, 11, 74, 16, 62, 03, 60, 94, 42, 47, 09, 34, 94, 93, 72],
[56, 18, 90, 18, 42, 17, 42, 32, 14, 86, 06, 53, 33, 95, 99, 35, 29, 15, 44, 20, 49, 59, 25, 54, 34, 59, 84, 21, 23, 54, 35, 90, 78, 16, 93, 13, 37, 88, 54, 19, 86, 67, 68, 55, 66, 84, 65, 42, 98, 37, 87, 56, 33, 28, 58, 38, 28, 38, 66, 27, 52, 21, 81, 15, 08, 22, 97, 32, 85, 27],
[91, 53, 40, 28, 13, 34, 91, 25, 01, 63, 50, 37, 22, 49, 71, 58, 32, 28, 30, 18, 68, 94, 23, 83, 63, 62, 94, 76, 80, 41, 90, 22, 82, 52, 29, 12, 18, 56, 10, 08, 35, 14, 37, 57, 23, 65, 67, 40, 72, 39, 93, 39, 70, 89, 40, 34, 07, 46, 94, 22, 20, 05, 53, 64, 56, 30, 05, 56, 61, 88, 27],
[23, 95, 11, 12, 37, 69, 68, 24, 66, 10, 87, 70, 43, 50, 75, 07, 62, 41, 83, 58, 95, 93, 89, 79, 45, 39, 02, 22, 05, 22, 95, 43, 62, 11, 68, 29, 17, 40, 26, 44, 25, 71, 87, 16, 70, 85, 19, 25, 59, 94, 90, 41, 41, 80, 61, 70, 55, 60, 84, 33, 95, 76, 42, 63, 15, 09, 03, 40, 38, 12, 03, 32],
[09, 84, 56, 80, 61, 55, 85, 97, 16, 94, 82, 94, 98, 57, 84, 30, 84, 48, 93, 90, 71, 05, 95, 90, 73, 17, 30, 98, 40, 64, 65, 89, 07, 79, 09, 19, 56, 36, 42, 30, 23, 69, 73, 72, 07, 05, 27, 61, 24, 31, 43, 48, 71, 84, 21, 28, 26, 65, 65, 59, 65, 74, 77, 20, 10, 81, 61, 84, 95, 08, 52, 23, 70],
[47, 81, 28, 09, 98, 51, 67, 64, 35, 51, 59, 36, 92, 82, 77, 65, 80, 24, 72, 53, 22, 07, 27, 10, 21, 28, 30, 22, 48, 82, 80, 48, 56, 20, 14, 43, 18, 25, 50, 95, 90, 31, 77, 08, 09, 48, 44, 80, 90, 22, 93, 45, 82, 17, 13, 96, 25, 26, 08, 73, 34, 99, 06, 49, 24, 06, 83, 51, 40, 14, 15, 10, 25, 01],
[54, 25, 10, 81, 30, 64, 24, 74, 75, 80, 36, 75, 82, 60, 22, 69, 72, 91, 45, 67, 03, 62, 79, 54, 89, 74, 44, 83, 64, 96, 66, 73, 44, 30, 74, 50, 37, 05, 09, 97, 70, 01, 60, 46, 37, 91, 39, 75, 75, 18, 58, 52, 72, 78, 51, 81, 86, 52, 08, 97, 01, 46, 43, 66, 98, 62, 81, 18, 70, 93, 73, 08, 32, 46, 34],
[96, 80, 82, 07, 59, 71, 92, 53, 19, 20, 88, 66, 03, 26, 26, 10, 24, 27, 50, 82, 94, 73, 63, 08, 51, 33, 22, 45, 19, 13, 58, 33, 90, 15, 22, 50, 36, 13, 55, 06, 35, 47, 82, 52, 33, 61, 36, 27, 28, 46, 98, 14, 73, 20, 73, 32, 16, 26, 80, 53, 47, 66, 76, 38, 94, 45, 02, 01, 22, 52, 47, 96, 64, 58, 52, 39],
[88, 46, 23, 39, 74, 63, 81, 64, 20, 90, 33, 33, 76, 55, 58, 26, 10, 46, 42, 26, 74, 74, 12, 83, 32, 43, 09, 02, 73, 55, 86, 54, 85, 34, 28, 23, 29, 79, 91, 62, 47, 41, 82, 87, 99, 22, 48, 90, 20, 05, 96, 75, 95, 04, 43, 28, 81, 39, 81, 01, 28, 42, 78, 25, 39, 77, 90, 57, 58, 98, 17, 36, 73, 22, 63, 74, 51],
[29, 39, 74, 94, 95, 78, 64, 24, 38, 86, 63, 87, 93, 06, 70, 92, 22, 16, 80, 64, 29, 52, 20, 27, 23, 50, 14, 13, 87, 15, 72, 96, 81, 22, 08, 49, 72, 30, 70, 24, 79, 31, 16, 64, 59, 21, 89, 34, 96, 91, 48, 76, 43, 53, 88, 01, 57, 80, 23, 81, 90, 79, 58, 01, 80, 87, 17, 99, 86, 90, 72, 63, 32, 69, 14, 28, 88, 69],
[37, 17, 71, 95, 56, 93, 71, 35, 43, 45, 04, 98, 92, 94, 84, 96, 11, 30, 31, 27, 31, 60, 92, 03, 48, 05, 98, 91, 86, 94, 35, 90, 90, 08, 48, 19, 33, 28, 68, 37, 59, 26, 65, 96, 50, 68, 22, 07, 09, 49, 34, 31, 77, 49, 43, 06, 75, 17, 81, 87, 61, 79, 52, 26, 27, 72, 29, 50, 07, 98, 86, 01, 17, 10, 46, 64, 24, 18, 56],
[51, 30, 25, 94, 88, 85, 79, 91, 40, 33, 63, 84, 49, 67, 98, 92, 15, 26, 75, 19, 82, 05, 18, 78, 65, 93, 61, 48, 91, 43, 59, 41, 70, 51, 22, 15, 92, 81, 67, 91, 46, 98, 11, 11, 65, 31, 66, 10, 98, 65, 83, 21, 05, 56, 05, 98, 73, 67, 46, 74, 69, 34, 08, 30, 05, 52, 07, 98, 32, 95, 30, 94, 65, 50, 24, 63, 28, 81, 99, 57],
[19, 23, 61, 36, 09, 89, 71, 98, 65, 17, 30, 29, 89, 26, 79, 74, 94, 11, 44, 48, 97, 54, 81, 55, 39, 66, 69, 45, 28, 47, 13, 86, 15, 76, 74, 70, 84, 32, 36, 33, 79, 20, 78, 14, 41, 47, 89, 28, 81, 05, 99, 66, 81, 86, 38, 26, 06, 25, 13, 60, 54, 55, 23, 53, 27, 05, 89, 25, 23, 11, 13, 54, 59, 54, 56, 34, 16, 24, 53, 44, 06],
[13, 40, 57, 72, 21, 15, 60, 08, 04, 19, 11, 98, 34, 45, 09, 97, 86, 71, 03, 15, 56, 19, 15, 44, 97, 31, 90, 04, 87, 87, 76, 08, 12, 30, 24, 62, 84, 28, 12, 85, 82, 53, 99, 52, 13, 94, 06, 65, 97, 86, 09, 50, 94, 68, 69, 74, 30, 67, 87, 94, 63, 07, 78, 27, 80, 36, 69, 41, 06, 92, 32, 78, 37, 82, 30, 05, 18, 87, 99, 72, 19, 99],
[44, 20, 55, 77, 69, 91, 27, 31, 28, 81, 80, 27, 02, 07, 97, 23, 95, 98, 12, 25, 75, 29, 47, 71, 07, 47, 78, 39, 41, 59, 27, 76, 13, 15, 66, 61, 68, 35, 69, 86, 16, 53, 67, 63, 99, 85, 41, 56, 08, 28, 33, 40, 94, 76, 90, 85, 31, 70, 24, 65, 84, 65, 99, 82, 19, 25, 54, 37, 21, 46, 33, 02, 52, 99, 51, 33, 26, 04, 87, 02, 08, 18, 96],
[54, 42, 61, 45, 91, 06, 64, 79, 80, 82, 32, 16, 83, 63, 42, 49, 19, 78, 65, 97, 40, 42, 14, 61, 49, 34, 04, 18, 25, 98, 59, 30, 82, 72, 26, 88, 54, 36, 21, 75, 03, 88, 99, 53, 46, 51, 55, 78, 22, 94, 34, 40, 68, 87, 84, 25, 30, 76, 25, 08, 92, 84, 42, 61, 40, 38, 09, 99, 40, 23, 29, 39, 46, 55, 10, 90, 35, 84, 56, 70, 63, 23, 91, 39],
[52, 92, 03, 71, 89, 07, 09, 37, 68, 66, 58, 20, 44, 92, 51, 56, 13, 71, 79, 99, 26, 37, 02, 06, 16, 67, 36, 52, 58, 16, 79, 73, 56, 60, 59, 27, 44, 77, 94, 82, 20, 50, 98, 33, 09, 87, 94, 37, 40, 83, 64, 83, 58, 85, 17, 76, 53, 02, 83, 52, 22, 27, 39, 20, 48, 92, 45, 21, 09, 42, 24, 23, 12, 37, 52, 28, 50, 78, 79, 20, 86, 62, 73, 20, 59],
[54, 96, 80, 15, 91, 90, 99, 70, 10, 09, 58, 90, 93, 50, 81, 99, 54, 38, 36, 10, 30, 11, 35, 84, 16, 45, 82, 18, 11, 97, 36, 43, 96, 79, 97, 65, 40, 48, 23, 19, 17, 31, 64, 52, 65, 65, 37, 32, 65, 76, 99, 79, 34, 65, 79, 27, 55, 33, 03, 01, 33, 27, 61, 28, 66, 08, 04, 70, 49, 46, 48, 83, 01, 45, 19, 96, 13, 81, 14, 21, 31, 79, 93, 85, 50, 05],
[92, 92, 48, 84, 59, 98, 31, 53, 23, 27, 15, 22, 79, 95, 24, 76, 05, 79, 16, 93, 97, 89, 38, 89, 42, 83, 02, 88, 94, 95, 82, 21, 01, 97, 48, 39, 31, 78, 09, 65, 50, 56, 97, 61, 01, 07, 65, 27, 21, 23, 14, 15, 80, 97, 44, 78, 49, 35, 33, 45, 81, 74, 34, 05, 31, 57, 09, 38, 94, 07, 69, 54, 69, 32, 65, 68, 46, 68, 78, 90, 24, 28, 49, 51, 45, 86, 35],
[41, 63, 89, 76, 87, 31, 86, 09, 46, 14, 87, 82, 22, 29, 47, 16, 13, 10, 70, 72, 82, 95, 48, 64, 58, 43, 13, 75, 42, 69, 21, 12, 67, 13, 64, 85, 58, 23, 98, 09, 37, 76, 05, 22, 31, 12, 66, 50, 29, 99, 86, 72, 45, 25, 10, 28, 19, 06, 90, 43, 29, 31, 67, 79, 46, 25, 74, 14, 97, 35, 76, 37, 65, 46, 23, 82, 06, 22, 30, 76, 93, 66, 94, 17, 96, 13, 20, 72],
[63, 40, 78, 08, 52, 09, 90, 41, 70, 28, 36, 14, 46, 44, 85, 96, 24, 52, 58, 15, 87, 37, 05, 98, 99, 39, 13, 61, 76, 38, 44, 99, 83, 74, 90, 22, 53, 80, 56, 98, 30, 51, 63, 39, 44, 30, 91, 91, 04, 22, 27, 73, 17, 35, 53, 18, 35, 45, 54, 56, 27, 78, 48, 13, 69, 36, 44, 38, 71, 25, 30, 56, 15, 22, 73, 43, 32, 69, 59, 25, 93, 83, 45, 11, 34, 94, 44, 39, 92],
[12, 36, 56, 88, 13, 96, 16, 12, 55, 54, 11, 47, 19, 78, 17, 17, 68, 81, 77, 51, 42, 55, 99, 85, 66, 27, 81, 79, 93, 42, 65, 61, 69, 74, 14, 01, 18, 56, 12, 01, 58, 37, 91, 22, 42, 66, 83, 25, 19, 04, 96, 41, 25, 45, 18, 69, 96, 88, 36, 93, 10, 12, 98, 32, 44, 83, 83, 04, 72, 91, 04, 27, 73, 07, 34, 37, 71, 60, 59, 31, 01, 54, 54, 44, 96, 93, 83, 36, 04, 45],
[30, 18, 22, 20, 42, 96, 65, 79, 17, 41, 55, 69, 94, 81, 29, 80, 91, 31, 85, 25, 47, 26, 43, 49, 02, 99, 34, 67, 99, 76, 16, 14, 15, 93, 08, 32, 99, 44, 61, 77, 67, 50, 43, 55, 87, 55, 53, 72, 17, 46, 62, 25, 50, 99, 73, 05, 93, 48, 17, 31, 70, 80, 59, 09, 44, 59, 45, 13, 74, 66, 58, 94, 87, 73, 16, 14, 85, 38, 74, 99, 64, 23, 79, 28, 71, 42, 20, 37, 82, 31, 23],
[51, 96, 39, 65, 46, 71, 56, 13, 29, 68, 53, 86, 45, 33, 51, 49, 12, 91, 21, 21, 76, 85, 02, 17, 98, 15, 46, 12, 60, 21, 88, 30, 92, 83, 44, 59, 42, 50, 27, 88, 46, 86, 94, 73, 45, 54, 23, 24, 14, 10, 94, 21, 20, 34, 23, 51, 04, 83, 99, 75, 90, 63, 60, 16, 22, 33, 83, 70, 11, 32, 10, 50, 29, 30, 83, 46, 11, 05, 31, 17, 86, 42, 49, 01, 44, 63, 28, 60, 07, 78, 95, 40],
[44, 61, 89, 59, 04, 49, 51, 27, 69, 71, 46, 76, 44, 04, 09, 34, 56, 39, 15, 06, 94, 91, 75, 90, 65, 27, 56, 23, 74, 06, 23, 33, 36, 69, 14, 39, 05, 34, 35, 57, 33, 22, 76, 46, 56, 10, 61, 65, 98, 09, 16, 69, 04, 62, 65, 18, 99, 76, 49, 18, 72, 66, 73, 83, 82, 40, 76, 31, 89, 91, 27, 88, 17, 35, 41, 35, 32, 51, 32, 67, 52, 68, 74, 85, 80, 57, 07, 11, 62, 66, 47, 22, 67],
[65, 37, 19, 97, 26, 17, 16, 24, 24, 17, 50, 37, 64, 82, 24, 36, 32, 11, 68, 34, 69, 31, 32, 89, 79, 93, 96, 68, 49, 90, 14, 23, 04, 04, 67, 99, 81, 74, 70, 74, 36, 96, 68, 09, 64, 39, 88, 35, 54, 89, 96, 58, 66, 27, 88, 97, 32, 14, 06, 35, 78, 20, 71, 06, 85, 66, 57, 02, 58, 91, 72, 05, 29, 56, 73, 48, 86, 52, 09, 93, 22, 57, 79, 42, 12, 01, 31, 68, 17, 59, 63, 76, 07, 77],
[73, 81, 14, 13, 17, 20, 11, 09, 01, 83, 08, 85, 91, 70, 84, 63, 62, 77, 37, 07, 47, 01, 59, 95, 39, 69, 39, 21, 99, 09, 87, 02, 97, 16, 92, 36, 74, 71, 90, 66, 33, 73, 73, 75, 52, 91, 11, 12, 26, 53, 05, 26, 26, 48, 61, 50, 90, 65, 01, 87, 42, 47, 74, 35, 22, 73, 24, 26, 56, 70, 52, 05, 48, 41, 31, 18, 83, 27, 21, 39, 80, 85, 26, 08, 44, 02, 71, 07, 63, 22, 05, 52, 19, 08, 20],
[17, 25, 21, 11, 72, 93, 33, 49, 64, 23, 53, 82, 03, 13, 91, 65, 85, 02, 40, 05, 42, 31, 77, 42, 05, 36, 06, 54, 04, 58, 07, 76, 87, 83, 25, 57, 66, 12, 74, 33, 85, 37, 74, 32, 20, 69, 03, 97, 91, 68, 82, 44, 19, 14, 89, 28, 85, 85, 80, 53, 34, 87, 58, 98, 88, 78, 48, 65, 98, 40, 11, 57, 10, 67, 70, 81, 60, 79, 74, 72, 97, 59, 79, 47, 30, 20, 54, 80, 89, 91, 14, 05, 33, 36, 79, 39],
[60, 85, 59, 39, 60, 07, 57, 76, 77, 92, 06, 35, 15, 72, 23, 41, 45, 52, 95, 18, 64, 79, 86, 53, 56, 31, 69, 11, 91, 31, 84, 50, 44, 82, 22, 81, 41, 40, 30, 42, 30, 91, 48, 94, 74, 76, 64, 58, 74, 25, 96, 57, 14, 19, 03, 99, 28, 83, 15, 75, 99, 01, 89, 85, 79, 50, 03, 95, 32, 67, 44, 08, 07, 41, 62, 64, 29, 20, 14, 76, 26, 55, 48, 71, 69, 66, 19, 72, 44, 25, 14, 01, 48, 74, 12, 98, 07],
[64, 66, 84, 24, 18, 16, 27, 48, 20, 14, 47, 69, 30, 86, 48, 40, 23, 16, 61, 21, 51, 50, 26, 47, 35, 33, 91, 28, 78, 64, 43, 68, 04, 79, 51, 08, 19, 60, 52, 95, 06, 68, 46, 86, 35, 97, 27, 58, 04, 65, 30, 58, 99, 12, 12, 75, 91, 39, 50, 31, 42, 64, 70, 04, 46, 07, 98, 73, 98, 93, 37, 89, 77, 91, 64, 71, 64, 65, 66, 21, 78, 62, 81, 74, 42, 20, 83, 70, 73, 95, 78, 45, 92, 27, 34, 53, 71, 15],
[30, 11, 85, 31, 34, 71, 13, 48, 05, 14, 44, 03, 19, 67, 23, 73, 19, 57, 06, 90, 94, 72, 57, 69, 81, 62, 59, 68, 88, 57, 55, 69, 49, 13, 07, 87, 97, 80, 89, 05, 71, 05, 05, 26, 38, 40, 16, 62, 45, 99, 18, 38, 98, 24, 21, 26, 62, 74, 69, 04, 85, 57, 77, 35, 58, 67, 91, 79, 79, 57, 86, 28, 66, 34, 72, 51, 76, 78, 36, 95, 63, 90, 08, 78, 47, 63, 45, 31, 22, 70, 52, 48, 79, 94, 15, 77, 61, 67, 68],
[23, 33, 44, 81, 80, 92, 93, 75, 94, 88, 23, 61, 39, 76, 22, 03, 28, 94, 32, 06, 49, 65, 41, 34, 18, 23, 08, 47, 62, 60, 03, 63, 33, 13, 80, 52, 31, 54, 73, 43, 70, 26, 16, 69, 57, 87, 83, 31, 03, 93, 70, 81, 47, 95, 77, 44, 29, 68, 39, 51, 56, 59, 63, 07, 25, 70, 07, 77, 43, 53, 64, 03, 94, 42, 95, 39, 18, 01, 66, 21, 16, 97, 20, 50, 90, 16, 70, 10, 95, 69, 29, 06, 25, 61, 41, 26, 15, 59, 63, 35]
]